The Journal

Dr. Van Beek

What 40 Years of Surgery Teaches You About Beauty

A surgical perspective on proportion, function, informed consent, and the responsibility to recommend less—or no intervention—when that better serves the patient.

Allen Van Beek, MD, FACS4 min read

After more than forty years in plastic and reconstructive surgery, I would frame the discussion of beauty around responsibility. A surgical recommendation changes living tissue. It requires more than an attractive photograph or a convincing description of technique. The question is whether a proposed change is appropriate for this person, at this time, with these particular goals and limitations.

My professional background includes reconstructive microsurgery as well as aesthetic care. The American Society for Reconstructive Microsurgery lists me among its founding members and records my presidency in 1990. Those are verifiable parts of a career; they are not guarantees of a particular cosmetic outcome. 2,3 Experience should make the consultation more thoughtful, not replace the need to explain a recommendation.

Function is part of appearance

Reconstructive thinking begins with what tissue must do. An eyelid must protect the eye. A facial nerve must support movement. A wound needs an adequate blood supply. Aesthetic planning should respect those same obligations. Improving a contour is not a sufficient reason to ignore the function of the structure being altered.

That principle changes the language of consultation. I would not describe an eyelid solely as skin to remove or a face solely as tissue to tighten. Each belongs to a moving, expressive system. The proposed improvement must be considered alongside what could be lost through excessive intervention. Beauty and function should be evaluated together.

Proportion matters more than an isolated ideal

A feature can look balanced on one face and excessive on another. A jawline is read in relation to the chin and neck; the eyes are read in relation to the brows and cheeks. There is no responsible way to reduce that assessment to one measurement or one preferred face.

I would ask what the patient hopes to preserve as carefully as what they hope to change. Family resemblance, ethnic characteristics, and features that carry personal meaning belong in the conversation. An older photograph may help communicate identity, but it should not become a promise to reproduce an earlier age. Surgical planning is an exercise in judgment, not historical duplication.

Listening is a clinical task

A statement such as “I look tired” is a starting point, not a diagnosis. The patient may mean heavy upper eyelids, lower-lid bags, skin changes, or a general feeling that their appearance no longer matches their energy. A useful consultation translates that concern into findings that can be examined and discussed.

The ASPS describes consultation as a review of goals, health, medications, previous procedures, photographs, options, anesthesia, and risks. 5 I consider that structure essential. The patient needs enough information to disagree, defer, or decide against surgery. A recommendation is more trustworthy when it can be questioned without pressure.

Restraint requires an explanation

“Less is more” is too vague to function as a surgical plan. Restraint means specifying what will be treated, what will remain, and why. It may mean correcting one concern while leaving another alone. It may mean postponing an operation when its burden is disproportionate to the likely benefit.

It also means recognizing the limits of appearance as a solution. A procedure cannot guarantee a relationship, a career opportunity, or lasting confidence. If the expected result extends far beyond the anatomical change, that mismatch deserves time and discussion. Choosing not to operate should be treated as a legitimate clinical conclusion, not a failed consultation.

Experience must remain accountable

A long career does not remove uncertainty. Complications can occur, and an attractive early result still needs follow-up. Informed consent should address the possibility of additional treatment, imperfect symmetry, visible scars, and an outcome that does not fully match expectations. Patient safety guidance emphasizes both questions before surgery and an ongoing relationship afterward. 4

The approach to care described in my North Memorial profile emphasizes informed, compassionate treatment and respect for dignity, privacy, and safety. 1 Those commitments are a more useful foundation than a claim of being the best. They can be reflected in the way a patient is examined, counseled, and cared for.

For me, the most defensible definition of beauty is one that leaves room for individuality and aging. The purpose of surgery is not to impose a standard face. It is to consider whether a specific, realistic change can serve the person who has asked for help—and whether the safest, most thoughtful answer might be a smaller intervention or no operation at all.

Sources and further reading

Clinical literature and professional guidance consulted October 22, 2026. First-person discussion reflects a clinical perspective; published evidence is identified through the numbered references.

  1. North Memorial Health: Allen L. Van Beek, MD, FACS
  2. American Society for Reconstructive Microsurgery: Founding members
  3. American Society for Reconstructive Microsurgery: Past presidents
  4. ASPS: Patient safety
  5. ASPS: Facelift consultation

Discuss your questions.

A consultation at our Edina practice is an opportunity to discuss your anatomy, options, and realistic expectations.

Request a consultation